Top Dog Training Tips

When it comes to crate training your dog, choosing the right type of crate can make all the difference. Two of the most popular options are Impact Dog Crates and plastic crates. Both have their advantages and drawbacks, but understanding their features and benefits will help you make the best choice for your dog’s needs.

In this article, we’ll compare Impact Dog Crates and plastic crates to see which is the better option for training. We’ll evaluate them based on durability, comfort, safety, portability, and training effectiveness.

1. Durability and Strength

Impact Dog Crates:

Impact Dog Crates are designed for heavy-duty use and can withstand even the most determined escape artists. Built from aluminum, they are both lightweight and incredibly durable, resisting chewing, scratching, and damage. These crates are ideal for powerful or anxious dogs prone to destructive behavior.

Plastic Crates:

Plastic crates are often made from molded plastic with a wire door. While they are suitable for light use and smaller dogs, they can break or crack under pressure, especially if your dog chews or pushes against the sides. They are not recommended for strong or highly anxious dogs.

Winner: Impact Dog Crates
For durability and strength, Impact Dog Crates clearly take the lead. Their rugged construction ensures long-lasting use, even for high-energy or aggressive dogs.

2. Comfort and Ventilation

Impact Dog Crates:

These crates come with ample ventilation through strategically placed holes or slots, promoting airflow and keeping your dog cool. The solid sides also give a den-like feel, which can make anxious dogs feel more secure. Adding a soft mat or bedding enhances comfort without sacrificing stability.

Plastic Crates:

Plastic crates have fewer ventilation holes, which can make them feel more enclosed. While this can be comforting for some dogs, it may cause overheating in warmer climates. The plastic material can also retain odors if not cleaned regularly.

Winner: Impact Dog Crates
The combination of ventilation and solid construction makes Impact Dog Crates more comfortable and suitable for a wider range of environments.

3. Safety and Security

Impact Dog Crates:

Safety is a top priority with Impact Dog Crates. The sturdy aluminum frame prevents escape, while secure latches keep the door firmly closed. Even the most determined dog won’t be able to break free.

Plastic Crates:

Plastic crates are more prone to damage and breakage. If a dog chews through the door or pushes hard against the sides, the crate can crack or deform, posing a risk to your pet’s safety.

Winner: Impact Dog Crates
For secure and worry-free training, Impact Dog Crates offer unparalleled protection.

4. Portability and Convenience

Impact Dog Crates:

Despite being made from durable aluminum, Impact Dog Crates are surprisingly lightweight and easy to move. Many models are designed to collapse for storage, making them convenient for travel or limited space.

Plastic Crates:

Plastic crates are typically bulkier and less convenient to transport. While they are lightweight, they lack the collapsible feature and can be awkward to carry, especially for larger sizes.

Winner: Impact Dog Crates
The portability and collapsible design make Impact Dog Crates the clear choice for on-the-go pet owners.

5. Training Effectiveness

Impact Dog Crates:

The sturdy and secure nature of Impact Dog Crates makes them highly effective for training stubborn or anxious dogs. Dogs quickly learn that this is a safe, comfortable space, which reduces stress and encourages good behavior.

Plastic Crates:

While suitable for short-term use or calm dogs, plastic crates lack the durability needed for long-term training or managing strong dogs. They may also feel too enclosed, leading to anxiety or discomfort during extended periods.

According to the National Library of Medicine (NIH), providing a secure and comfortable environment significantly reduces stress and improves behavioral outcomes. Impact Dog Crates’ design aligns well with these findings, making them superior for effective training.

Winner: Impact Dog Crates
With a focus on security and comfort, these crates make training smoother and less stressful for both the dog and the owner.

6. Price and Long-Term Value

Impact Dog Crates:

While these crates may have a higher upfront cost, their durability and long lifespan make them a wise investment. You won’t have to worry about replacements or repairs, which saves money in the long run.

Plastic Crates:

Plastic crates are generally cheaper but often require replacements after damage or wear. The cost of multiple replacements can add up quickly.

Winner: Impact Dog Crates
Considering the long-term value and reliability, investing in an Impact Dog Crate makes more sense for serious dog owners.

Final Verdict: Which Crate is Best for Training?

When it comes to crate training, Impact Dog Crates outperform plastic crates in almost every category. They provide:

• Unmatched durability and escape resistance
• Enhanced comfort with proper ventilation
• Maximum safety and security
• Portability and convenience for travel
• Effective training outcomes with positive reinforcement

While plastic crates may be suitable for small, calm dogs or short-term use, Impact Dog Crates are the ultimate choice for serious training, long-term use, and managing stubborn or anxious dogs.Choosing a high-quality crate like those from Impact Dog Crates ensures your dog has a safe, secure, and comfortable space that promotes positive behavior and well-being. Don’t settle for less—invest in a crate that truly supports your dog’s training journey and enhances their overall comfort and security.